How to create an icon from an image? November 6th 2005

This tutorial describes how to make icons from images in RealWorld Icon Editor and explains how to prepare images to attain best possible results.

Reader of this guide should be familiar with basic terms related to computer images and icons as discussed in articles about computer images and Windows XP icons.

Overview

Icon is a container of several images, where each image is optimized for specific color depth and screen resolution. When creating icons from image, the task is to resample the image to specified sizes and adjust it to specified color depths.

An image with alpha channel and an icon generated from the image.

Since an icon usually has a transparent background, the conversion should either use transparency information from the source image or determine the transparency using another method.

Converting images to icons in RealWorld Icon Editor

This is a three-step process:

1. Open a supported image. The application understands these standard formats: PNG, JPG, GIF, TIF, JPEG2000, TGA, PCX, PSD, and BMP.
2. Optionally, select a region with the Transform tool. Then activate the Create icon commands in Create menu or in the toolbar.
3. After finishing step 2, a new window is opened. Use this window to modify your new icon and to save it.

An icon is created from image by clicking on Create icon toolbar button.

The application comes with a pre-configured image to icon converter with standard image formats. Users may add their own or modify the default image formats.

The source image

An icon is only as good as the image it is created from. For best results, follow these guidelines:

• Use a square source images. While the transformation will keep aspect ratio and center the image if needed, it is best to use a square image. This gives you the option to align the object as you need. (Also, when using less sophisticated icon editors, your icon may become deformed.)
• Use large-enough source images. If the source is 3x-5x larger than largest generated image, the result icon is likely to have nice smooth edges.
• The image should not have any unnecessary empty borders. Icons are small and cannot afford to waste any space.

As mentioned earlier, icons have transparent background. Best results are obtained if source images already have correct alpha channel (use an adequate file format such as PNG). RealWorld Icon Editor can create icons even from images that are missing an alpha channel, although there are additional conditions.

Images without alpha channel

If the original image does not have an alpha channel, the color of the first pixel (or a user defined color) is assumed to be background and it is considered transparent. Make sure that the background color is never used in the actual image (hint: do not use white or black as a background color). Also, avoid using images with smooth edges. If an object is mixed with background, it is virtually impossible to remove all traces of the background.

Good (large, square, no borders) image for image to icon conversion.	Bad image for icon conversion: it is small, has redundant empty borders, its edges are blended with background.
Icon created from the left image. A shadow effect was used to enhance object's outline.	Icon from the right image is smaller than necessary, has wrong proportions, and an unwanted cyan outline.

Images with artifacts

If a source image is stored using a lossy image format such as JPG, it contains artifacts. Images with artifacts are not suitable, because background and foreground are mixed and the application is unable to separate them. This is similar to the problem with smooth edges.

Fixing an unsuitable source image

A raster image editor integrated in RealWorld Icon Editor can help you fix most problems with source images and prepare them for conversion to icon.

To edit an opened image, click 'Edit as Raster Image' command in 'Document' menu or on toolbar. The application window is now showing the image in edit mode. Enable alpha channel in 'Document'->'Raster Image Properties' dialog and use the Flood Fill tool to remove background manually (replace it with transparent color). Experiment with the tolerance parameter of the Flood Fill tool to remove image artifacts and/or antialiased outline.

Once the background is fixed, switch to the 'Image Viewer' layout. Activate the 'Remove Borders' operation in 'Document' menu to automatically remove empty borders and center image in the smallest square possible. The image is now ready and you may use it to create a new icon by clicking one of the 'Create Icon' commands.

Advanced features

RealWorld Icon Editor offers two unique features related to image to icon conversion.

Applying effects during conversion

Almost all Windows XP icons have some kind of shadow or outline enhancement effect. These effects, when used appropriately, give icons uniform style and improve the recognition speed by emphasizing important features of an image. It is of course possible to incorporate these effects into the source image manually, but it would be a lot of work, because:

• The effect should be similar on all icons that are used together. Therefore the size of source images should either be the same or the size of the effect must be relative to the source image size.
• Different image sizes in an icon require different effects. To get perfect results you would need to apply different effects on each generated image.

No shadow - contours are hard to recognize.

Simple shadow improves look and feel.

Custom shadow for each image in an icon.

RealWorld Icon Editor can do the above automatically. It is of course customizable and you may easily change your preferences for a single icon or on a project basis.

Optimizing pre-XP icons

Prior to Windows XP, pixels in icons were either fully transparent or fully opaque. These icons had jagged edges, because smooth edges require semitransparent pixels. These images are still present in Windows XP icons and they are used when color depth of the screen is set to Hi-Color or lower or when an icon is used on older Windows. More information in article about XP icons.

RealWorld Icon Editor allows optimizing pre-XP icons for predefined background color. These icons perform well on all kinds of light backgrounds, especially on toolbars, in menus, and dialogs. The ultimate choice is of course yours. You may enable or disable optimized pre-XP icons in the configuration dialog of the image to icon transformation.

Standard pre-XP icon.

Pre-XP optimization improves edges.

Optimized icon with shadow effect applied.

The same icons on a gray background. This is the color of Windows 2000 toolbars.
The quality of the optimized icons is getting close to Windows XP icon quality.

Summary

After reading this tutorial, you should know what is involved in an image to icon transformation, you should also know how to spot unsuitable images, how to fix them, and how to create icons in RealWorld Icon Editor.

This article covered only the basic techniques. If you cannot find certain feature or feel that something is more complicated then it should be, please leave your comment here or in the support forum. There is a good chance that a solution for your problem already exists.